Thursday, March 23, 2023

Can Businesses Ask For Proof Of Vaccination

Can A Business Ask For Proof Of Vaccination

As businesses adjust to mask requirements, can they ask for proof of vaccination?

Subject to state laws, businesses can ask for customers to demonstrate proof of vaccination, but due to laws such as ADA cannot flatly refuse to provide a service to the customer if they cannot prove their vaccination status. Instead, if a customer has not been vaccinated or refuses to disclose their vaccination status, businesses can require the customer to wear a mask or can organize an outside delivery of their purchase. If the customer refuses to agree to the compromise, businesses can then refuse to provide a service on health and safety grounds.

Is It A Hipaa Violation To Ask About Covid Vaccines

No. Any organization can ask any employee, customer, or relevant third party whether or not they have been vaccinated against COVID-19 without violating HIPAA. However, before asking the question, organizations should be prepared for how they will respond to individuals´ answers, or how they will respond if an individual refuses to answer the question.

Vaccine Passports Emerge As The Easiest Way To Do So

For those set on requiring proof of vaccination from customers, how to do so is the question thats top of mind. While CDC vaccination cards may work for the moment, paper records are not a long-term solution. Since they can be forged or misplaced, many companies are turning to a digital vaccine passport.

While President Biden has ruled out any chance of a federal vaccine passport program or requirement, the private sector has long been working on developing a digital solution.

CommonPass and Health Pass are two apps that allow individuals to prove their vaccination status via a scannable QR code on their phone. Health Pass was created by Clear, the same company responsible for ushering users through airport security. It is already being used to gain entry to NBA games and will likely see expanded adoption across other sporting arenas.

Requiring proof of vaccination is perfectly legal as long as there is no state law against it. Business owners must make the decision that best suits their businesss needs, while protecting staff and customers. For some, this may mean requiring vaccines as a prerequisite for service. Other business owners will choose to take precautionary measures, like enforcing social distancing and mask wearing for all.

Also Check: Does Cvs Give Tetanus Shots

Hipaa And Proof Of Vaccine Status

Vaccination information is classed as PHI and is covered by the HIPAA Rules. However, HIPAA only applies to HIPAA-covered entities healthcare providers, health plans, and healthcare clearinghouses and their business associates. If an employer asks an employee to provide proof that they have been vaccinated in order to allow that individual to work without wearing a facemask, that is not a HIPAA violation as HIPAA does not apply to most employers.

It would not be a HIPAA violation for an employer to ask an employees healthcare provider for proof of vaccination. It would however be a HIPAA violation for the employees healthcare provider to disclose that information to the employer unless the individual had provided authorization to do so. If an employer is running their own vaccination program and an employee chooses to have their vaccine privately, that individual may have to authorize their healthcare provider to disclose certain information about their vaccine to their employer as proof that they have been vaccinated.

Asking about vaccine status would not violate HIPAA but it is possible that other laws could be violated. For instance, requiring employees to disclose additional health information such as the reason why they are not vaccinated could potentially violate federal laws. Furthermore, several states have passed laws or are considering laws that prohibit employers in the public sector from asking employees about their vaccine status.

Sport And Recreational Fitness

Health Ministry to verify vaccination cards

Starting on December 20, 2021, Ontario will require proof of vaccination for youth aged 12 to 17 years of age participating in organized sports at recreational facilities.

Anyone entering to work or volunteer, including coaches and officials, do not need to provide proof of vaccination, proof of medical exemption, or proof of participation in a Health Canada approved vaccine trial.

Don’t Miss: Does Cvs Offer Tdap Shot

More Businesses Want Proof Of Vaccination: Lawyer

A Toronto-based privacy lawyer says an increasing number of Canadian businesses are considering putting policies in place that would require customers to provide proof of COVID-19 jabs before receiving service.

Molly Reynolds says a lot of businesses have been approaching her because they say they want to protect customers and employees as public health restrictions lift across the country.

“There are businesses of really every size, and in really every industry, who are thinking about this,” Reynolds, a lawyer with Torys LLP, said in an interview Wednesday.

” in terms of what should they be doing to protect their customers and protect their employees and then also thinking whether any centralized provincial or federal government vaccine passports might be tools that they can use as part of considering rules around access to their premises.”

No tool currently exists and no public health authority in Canada currently requires businesses to ask for proof of vaccination, such as a document or a verbal confirmation. But no one has said they can’t do it either, Reynolds said.

“It really places that burden back on businesses to make their own assessments, because there isn’t regulatory or governmental guidance that they can align with,” she said.

Reynolds noted that businesses considering such a policy should be able to show that the privacy infringement is worth it if it protects communal health.

Is It A Hipaa Violation To Ask About Vaccinations

It is not a HIPAA violation to ask about vaccinations against COVID-19. However, it is advisable for HIPAA-Covered Entities and organizations subject to other privacy protection laws to amend Privacy Policy Notices to ensure individuals know why they are being asked about their vaccination status and how the information will be protected.

Don’t Miss: Does Cvs Do Tdap Shots

Can Bars Or Restaurants Ask For Vaccine Proof Or Deny Service

The laws around this can be a bit confusing. The federal law states that private businesses can ask customers and employees about their vaccine status. They just have to be careful not to ask for other medical info.

However, some states like Florida have passed executive orders to stop businesses from asking customers about their COVID-19 vaccine status. But some San Francisco and New York bars and restaurants are asking customers for proof of vaccination or negative test results.

No It Is Not Illegal For Businesses To Require Proof Of Vaccination

Navigating vaccine card confusion

A healthcare worker prepares Moderna COVID-19 vaccines for farmworkers at a County of Santa Clara mobile vaccination clinic at Monterey Mushrooms in Morgan Hill, Calif., Wednesday, March 3, 2021.

AP Photo/Jeff Chiu

If your time is short:

  • An image shared on Instagram and Twitter claimed businesses cannot legally require customers to provide proof of vaccination or deny entry based on vaccination status.
  • The image cites the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution and Title III of the U.S. Civil Rights Act, but experts say the Fourth Amendment applies only to government entities and Title III of the U.S. Civil Rights Act makes no mention of discrimination based on a medical condition.
  • Private businesses cannot discriminate on the basis of race, gender, religion, national origin or disability, but otherwise, they have the right to conduct transactions with whomever they choose.
  • Experts say businesses would likely have to try to provide reasonable accommodations for customers who cant be vaccinated because of a disability or religious beliefs before they can refuse service.

An image appearing on Instagram and Twitter claims that businesses cannot legally require customers to provide proof of vaccination or deny entry based on vaccination status. The graphic cited the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution and Title III of the U.S. Civil Rights Act.

None of that is accurate, but nonetheless, the false information has been spreading.

What Are Your Rights?

The Penalty

Also Check: Does Cvs Pharmacy Give Tdap Vaccine

Wedding Services Rites Ceremony And Funeral Services

People do not need to provide proof of vaccination, proof of medical exemption, or proof of participation in a Health Canada approved vaccine trial to enter an indoor meeting or event space:

  • to attend a wedding service, rite, ceremony or funeral service but, do need proof of vaccination for an associated social gathering
  • in a place of worship, funeral establishment, cemetery or crematorium to attend a social gathering associated with a funeral service, rite or ceremony

Is My Employer Permitted To Ask Questions About My Covid

Can My Employer Ask About My COVID-19 Vaccination Status?

Yes. Disability discrimination is illegal so, in general, employers may not ask employees medical questions that might reveal the existence of a physical or mental disability. There are certain exceptions to this rule. Asking about an employees COVID-19 vaccination status is one of them. Discrimination laws do not prohibit employers from requiring all employees who physically enter the workplace to be vaccinated. It is not illegal for an employer to ask employees to provide documentation or other proof of vaccination. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has issued guidance the relationship between COVID-19 vaccination status and federal employment laws. The guidance can be viewed here.

What if I Have a Disability or Religious Beliefs That Prevent Me From Being Vaccinated?

Some people are unable to tolerate COVID-19 vaccines due to a disability. Some people have sincerely held religious beliefs that prevent them from getting vaccinated. Employees with disabilities and religious belief that prevent them from being vaccinated are entitled to reasonable accommodation.

Reasonable Accommodations Are Decided on a Case-by-Case Basis

If an employee who cannot be vaccinated for disability-related or religious reasons has the ability to perform the essential functions of their job from home, that might be a reasonable accommodation. Working in a separate office or location is another possibility.

Recommended Reading: Where To Get Tdap Vaccine Cvs

Fines For Businesses Requiring Vaccination Proof

Starting Thursday, Florida businesses can be fined $5,000 if they ask you to prove youre vaccinated. But the statute may not be constitutional, and the rules could be different if businesses ask for a negative COVID-19 test instead.

The difference is that the statute specifically states you cant require documentation of vaccination status from customers, but it doesnt specifically say that you cant require a negative COVID-19 test when they come in. Everything beside the physical paper document that says someone has been vaccinated is fair game.

Some legal experts we spoke with say there are numerous other ways for business owners to get around this. The statute also doesnt rule out someone verbally asking you if youre vaccinated, or charging you a different price if youre not vaccinated. It simply comes down to the fact that, from a First Amendment standpoint, theyre trying to get to the same end but using different means to get there, means that arent specifically outlawed.

Theyre restricting you from doing one thing, as opposed to another thing, said Scott Atwood, chair of employment law group Henderson Franklin. And if then the government gets in the way and says that you cant require or not require them to do one thing and try to get to the same endgame, then you can get in trouble. So its the same as saying that you cant have one type of flag, and then put another type of a flagpole in your front lawn.

If An Individual Discloses Their Vaccination Status Voluntarily Do They Forgo Hipaa Protections

Can a business require proof of vaccination for COVID

No. If an individual voluntarily discloses their vaccination status to a HIPAA Covered Entity or Business Associate, the information they have provided is still protected under the HIPAA Security and privacy Rules. If an individual voluntarily discloses their vaccination status to an entity not covered by HIPAA, the disclosure is not subject to HIPAA Rules.

Don’t Miss: Cvs Tdap Vaccine Schedule

Ask For Qr Code And Personal Id

Ask the patron for their:

You will need to visually inspect your patron’s vaccination receipt if:

  • your patron does not have an enhanced vaccine certificate with a QR code
  • your patron has a vaccine receipt from outside of Ontario, from an Indigenous Health provider or from the Canadian Forces
  • your patrons QR code scans yellow on the Verify Ontario app

An Faq On What You Can And Cant Do Regarding Your Employees Vaccination Status

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention no longer recommends mandatory mask-wearing or social distancing for people who are vaccinated. However, this is just guidance, because if state or local laws contradict the CDC, then state or local laws take precedence.

But in the areas where the CDC guidance is the top authority, asking staff about their vaccination status can be important, but with significant privacy considerations. On the one hand, an employees vaccination status is their own private health information, but on the other hand, an employees vaccination status also determines whether or not they need to wear a mask and socially distance at work.

  • Can I ask my employees if they are vaccinated?

    Employers are allowed to ask their employees about their vaccination status.

  • Is asking a violation of the Health Information Portability and Accountability Act ?

    No, because HIPAA establishes restrictions on sharing information, not asking. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has explicitly said that employers are allowed to ask their employees about their vaccination status.

  • Can I ask my employee for proof of vaccination?

    Yes, you can. The EEOC allows you to obtain proof of receipt of COVID-19 vaccination from your employees, and its likely that you can also request a copy of their vaccination card or documentation of their vaccination status.

  • Also Check: Can I Get Tdap At Cvs

    What Qualifies As Proof Of Vaccination

    Support among Americans for some form of vaccine verification depends on the type of activity. According to a survey conducted by Gallup in April, 57% of U.S. adults support verification for air travel while 55% back verifying vaccination status for attending a large event like a concert. However, only 40% support showing proof if you want to dine indoors at a restaurant.

    While there are laws requiring businesses to make accommodations for people with disabilities and for those who refuse to get vaccinated for religious reasons, establishments can still require customers prove their status.

    “Its newer legal ground but most likely so long as the businesses have a justification and they exempt people based on those reasons, they would most likely be legally permissible,” said Alison Hoffman, professor at the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School and an expert on health law and policy.

    The issues facing businesses might be more practical than legal. Hoffman said businesses are on “difficult and somewhat tenuous ground” trying to determine what qualifies as proof of vaccination. The closest available documentation Americans have is the CDC vaccination record card supplied and updated by vaccine providers after doses.

    Then there’s the challenge of what to do if someone can’t offer proof or doesn’t want to share that information.

    Can Employers Require Employees To Be Vaccinated

    Can Businesses Legally Require Proof Of Vaccination?

    No individual is required to have a vaccine, as they have the choice whether or not to be vaccinated, but there can be consequences for employees who refuse a vaccine on non-medical or non-religious grounds depending on state regulations. However, just as an employer can require all employees to wear a uniform in the workplace, an employer can have a policy that requires employees to wear a facemask during a pandemic. They are also within their rights to refuse entry to the workplace if a mask is not worn contrary to a workplace policy in order to protect other members of the workforce or customers.

    The Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires employers to provide reasonable accommodations for employees who have strongly held religious beliefs, and the ADA requires employers to provide reasonable accommodations for employees who have an underlying disability under the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Accommodations therefore need to be made for individuals who have refused a vaccine on these grounds.

    Read Also: Pertussis Vaccine Cvs

    What You Need To Know

    • A vaccine passport is a centralized means of proving a personhas been vaccinated. It is only one form of proof of vaccination.Vaccine passport systems in the European Union and elsewhere couldinform what a Canadian vaccine passport may look like.
    • In contrast, business-specific proof of vaccination programsare not centralized, but rather based on collecting data directlyfrom individuals.
    • Businesses should consider a wide range of factors in theirprivacy risk analysis before implementing a proof of vaccinationprogram. These include:
    • whether the program is optional or mandatory
    • the rationale for the collection of vaccination statusinformation and the availability of alternative health-protectivemeasures
    • access, discrimination, and human rights concerns and
    • the means of proof and validation.
  • In such dynamic circumstances, businesses should be prepared torevisit their risk analysis as the factual and regulatory landscapechanges.
  • What If You Dont Comply With Vaccine Requirements

    If you decline to get the COVID-19 vaccination for reasons other than those related to religious or disability purposes, your company may choose to no longer employ you. Your specific situation will depend on your companys guidelines and requirements.

    Some companies will want to ensure your status. They may require you to show proof of COVID-19 vaccination or have employees complete weekly submissions of a COVID-19 test.

    Guidelines change and update constantly. Its important to check your company or schools requirements to ensure you stay prepared.

    You May Like: Cheapest Shingles Shot

    How To Ask For Proof Of Vaccination

    Its clear that vaccines have become a thorny issue. Some camps say requiring vaccines infringes on personal liberties, while others say there is an existing societal and legal precedent for this matter, as many institutions have long required proof of vaccination.

    One rumor circulating on the internet is that asking customers to show proof of vaccination violates the health insurance portability and accountability act . This is untrue.

    Simply asking for information does not violate HIPAA. Disclosing or using information without permission and unlawfully is the violation, said Andrew Rozo, a NY-based attorney who practices health law.

    Simply asking for information does not violate HIPAA. Disclosing or using information without permission and unlawfully is the violation, said Andrew Rozo, a NY-based attorney who practices health law.

    HIPAA is designed to prevent health care professionals from revealing health information about patients. But you or I can freely tell anyone we want to about our health, and employers do not violate HIPAA by asking for your information either, Rozo said.

    Despite the legality of asking patrons to prove theyve been vaccinated, businesses could risk alienating customers by doing so. Especially as many retailers, restaurants, and small businesses have struggled since the pandemic began, many business owners dont want to risk backlash.

    Popular Articles
    Related news