Wednesday, September 20, 2023

Can Employers Ask If You Are Vaccinated

Does Your Employer Have To Tell You If Someone In The Workplace Has Covid

Yes, your employer can ask if you’re vaccinated. No, HIPAA doesn’t protect you in that case.

The federal Americans with Disabilities Act covers both disabilities and medical conditions or illnesses, Maslanka said.

Under the ADA, an employer is allowed to tell other workers if someone in the workplace tests positive, but they arent allowed to identify that person, he said.

It is permissible to speak generically about that person, he said, By way of example: Theres someone on the fourth floor who has been exposed, who has COVID. Were going to be interviewing you all to find out whether you have any COVID symptoms. That generic statement is permissible.

If an employee gives their employer permission to tell others they have COVID-19, then an employer can identify them. While the law doesnt require the permission to be written, its good practice to put it in writing, Maslanka said.

There are circumstances where employees will naturally be able to figure out who has the virus if their boss notifies them generically, Maslanka said. But as long as the employer doesnt identify them without permission, its not a violation.

Maybe Joe works with five other people on the fourth floor, and Joe takes a leave of absence, he said. Now the employees are going to be able to figure it out. But the law says and the says, you let the employees figure that out themselves.

No Jab No Job Can My Employer Make Me Get A Covid

Written byLaura Kearsley

Since the rollout of the Government Covid-19 vaccine programme, which began in December, just over 46 million people in the UK have now received at least one dose of a vaccine. However, there are still several people who have still not taken up the offer of a vaccine yet, despite being eligible to receive one.

Previously, the Prime Minister stated that every adult would be offered a vaccine by the end of this month, which left UK-based workers wondering whether they would have to have the jab and whether their employer can require them to be immunised.

Continuing With Other Public Health Measures

Vaccines play a critical role in reducing risks of COVID-19 infection and transmission. They are something all businesses should consider as part of their health and safety activities and assessments. Vaccination supports, and does not replace, other infection prevention and control measures. Workers, representatives and unions should be involved in this process.

Under the Health and Safety at Work Act, businesses must take steps to eliminate or otherwise minimise risks, including the use of personal protective equipment and cleaning, where recommended under public health guidance.

Businesses and other organisations should continue to encourage use of the NZ COVID Tracer app by clearly displaying QR codes, and must follow Alert Level or COVID Protection Framework rules.

Recommended Reading: Is The Flu Vaccine Available

Is It A Hipaa Violation To Ask About Vaccinations

It is not a HIPAA violation to ask about vaccinations against COVID-19. However, it is advisable for HIPAA-Covered Entities and organizations subject to other privacy protection laws to amend Privacy Policy Notices to ensure individuals know why they are being asked about their vaccination status and how the information will be protected.

Can Employers Demand Vaccination

Employers can bar unvaccinated employees from the ...

While employers can make vaccines necessary in their policies, whether those requirements would hold up if challenged is another matter, says Hermie Abraham, an employment lawyer and the owner of Advocation Professional Corporation.

Because the federal and provincial governments have so far refrained from making the COVID-19 vaccine mandatory, its unlikely that workplace policies that do so will stand if tested in court or through arbitration, Abraham says.

Read more: Vaccine uptick a chance to get Canadas most vulnerable a 2nd dose and sooner

Requiring a medical procedure such as a vaccine could be considered a breach of privacy or a human rights violation, says Lior Samfiru, partner at Samfiru Tumarkin LLP.

A legal kerfuffle between Torontos St. Michaels Hospital and the Ontario Nurses Association is a recent legal precedent for whether employers can mandate vaccinations, both Abraham and Samfiru say.

In 2018, an arbitrator struck down a policy by St. Michaels to force nurses who had not received the flu vaccine to wear surgical masks following a grievance filed by the ONA.

Read more: Canadas Medicago says its COVID-19 vaccine shows promising antibody results in trial

Arbitrator William Kaplan called the policy unsustainable and illogical given poor evidence that surgical masks prevent transmission of the flu and that the hospital did not require unvaccinated visitors to mask up, among other reasons.

Recommended Reading: How Much Is Pneumonia Vaccine

Does The Same Apply With Regards To Negative Covid Tests And Hipaa

Yes. If an employer requests evidence of a negative COVID test before allowing an employee to return to work, or a university requests evidence of a negative COVID test before allowing a student to resume in-person tuition, neither is in violation of HIPAA law provided neither is a HIPAA Covered Entity nor Business Associate.

Employer Incentives For Covid

ADA: Employer Incentives for Voluntary COVID-19 Vaccinations

K.16. Under the ADA, may an employer offer an incentive to employees to voluntarily provide documentation or other confirmation that they received a vaccination on their own from a pharmacy, public health department, or other health care provider in the community?

Yes. Requesting documentation or other confirmation showing that an employee received a COVID-19 vaccination in the community is not a disability-related inquiry covered by the ADA. Therefore, an employer may offer an incentive to employees to voluntarily provide documentation or other confirmation of a vaccination received in the community. As noted elsewhere, the employer is required to keep vaccination information confidential pursuant to the ADA.

K.17. Under the ADA, may an employer offer an incentive to employees for voluntarily receiving a vaccination administered by the employer or its agent?

GINA: Employer Incentives for Voluntary COVID-19 Vaccinations

K.18. Under GINA, may an employer offer an incentive to employees to provide documentation or other confirmation that they or their family members received a vaccination from their own health care provider, such as a doctor, pharmacy, health agency, or another health care provider in the community?

K.19. Under GINA, may an employer offer an incentive to employees in exchange for the employee getting vaccinated by the employer or its agent?

You May Like: When Do You Get Mmr Vaccine

I Am Looking For Work Will I Have To Tell Prospective Employers Whether Or Not I Have Been Vaccinated

There is a general prohibition on employers asking prospective employees health-related questions, which in this case would include their vaccination records. Although, there are limited exceptions to this that could apply to sectors and job roles where there is a particular health and safety reason, meaning the employer needs to know whether youve been vaccinated or not.

In addition, employers could make job offers conditional on proof of having been vaccinated. Pimlico Plumbers boss, Charlie Mullins, has confirmed that this is the approach that his business is adopting.

This is lawful as long as the employer does not discriminate against any disabled candidates who are unable to have the vaccine as a result of their disability or expectant mothers who are unsure whether to have the jab as a result of their pregnancy.

Employers will also need to remember that those under 18 years of age are not yet eligible to receive the vaccine and so any requirement for them, could be indirectly discriminatory on grounds of age.

I Want All My Employees To Be Vaccinated

Is it legal for an employer to ask if you are vaccinated?

If an employer feels it’s important for staff to be vaccinated, they should talk together with staff or the organisation’s recognised trade union to discuss what steps to take. Any decision after that discussion should be put in writing, for example in a workplace vaccination or testing policy. It must also be in line with the organisation’s existing disciplinary and grievance policy. It’s best to support staff to get the vaccine without forcing them to do so.

You May Like: Do You Need Vaccinations To Go To Thailand

Can I Make A Complaint If I Think My Employer Is Misusing My Vaccination Status Information

If you think your employer is misusing your vaccination status information, you should contact your employer in the first instance to try to resolve the issue with them.

If you are not satisfied with your employers response, you can lodge a complaint with the OAIC if your employer is a Commonwealth or Norfolk Island Government agency or an organisation covered by the Privacy Act. The Privacy Act covers organisations with an annual turnover of more than $3 million and some other organisations, such as:

  • private sector health service providers
  • businesses that sell or purchase personal information
  • contracted service providers for an Australian Government contract.

If the employee records exception applies, you may be able to make a complaint about the collection practices of your employer, such as the fact that your employer has asked to collect your vaccination status information where it is not necessary or in relation to the APP 5 information that they have provided to you. This is because the employee records exemption only exempts personal information from the Privacy Act once it has been included in an employee record.

You can find more information about our complaints process here.

Can My Employer Ask If Im Vaccinated

Weve had a lot of calls recently asking whether employers can ask employees if theyve had the vaccine for COVID-19. Some employees believe that asking about vaccination status is a violation of HIPAA rights. Some employees want to know if an employer can ask for proof of vaccination, or just has to take the employees word for it. Some employees want to know if, beyond asking about vaccination status, an employer can require employees to be vaccinated or provide incentives for vaccinated employees.

It may surprise some people to learn that the answers to all of these questions are not new. The COVID virus and vaccine are relatively new to the world and to the realm of employment law, but the rules and regulations surrounding vaccination status and the other laws that come into play are well-established and relatively clear.

Gold Star Law is not a professional medical organization and is not qualified to give medical advice. Gold Star Laws position is that people should follow the advice of their doctors and medical professionals.

If you need help with an employment law problem, contact us.

Read Also: Is It Safe To Get Vaccinated While Pregnant

Other Considerations For Rapid Antigen Screening

Employers must make sure that all requirements described in the COVID-19covid 19 Guidance: Considerations for Antigen Point-of-Care Testing, or updated guidance as it becomes available, are being followed when using rapid antigen testing as part of workplace screening.

Employers should tell their local public health unit if they will be doing rapid antigen screening.

Employers using rapid antigen screening should develop a policy related to COVID-19covid 19 testing. This should be based on independent legal advice, which may include recommendations on issues of:

  • human rights and accessibility

When Screening Is Passed

Can a business ask if you

If a worker or non-worker passes all steps in the screening they:

  • may enter the workplace at that time
  • must continue to follow all public health and workplace control measures, including:
  • wearing a mask
  • hand hygiene
  • should continue to self-monitor for new symptoms
  • should follow their workplaceâs reporting procedure, if they are a worker and develop symptoms during their shift
  • Also Check: What Age Do You Vaccinate For Meningitis

    Compulsory Vaccinations For Workers

    This week, MPs approved compulsory vaccinations for care home staff in England, which means that from October, all care home workers ) will be required to receive two doses of a Covid-19 vaccine, unless they have a medical exemption. The Government has also previously said that it is considering making jabs compulsory for NHS workers.

    With all Covid-19 restrictions being relaxed on Monday, 19th July, the majority of employers will understandably be very keen for their staff to benefit from a vaccine. Having a full complement of vaccinated employees will mean a dramatic reduction in the risk of the virus and less concern for the employer when it comes to transmission in the workplace. That being said, it might not necessarily be as simple as they think.

    Below, we have answered several employment law questions from workers concerning Covid-19 vaccines.

    Is Asking For Proof Of Vaccination Discriminatory

    If the workplace or job requires that the employee be vaccinated, asking for proof of vaccination would not be discriminatory, says Marie-Hélène Jetté, head of the labour and employment law group for Langlois Lawyers in Montreal, with some exceptions provided for in human rights legislation.

    Human rights laws ban discrimination and require employers to make accommodations to the point of undue hardship, notes the publication HR Insider in an article on requiring employees to provide proof of COVID-19 vaccination. For example, employers arent generally allowed to ask employees or job applicants about their disabilities requiring proof of vaccination may discriminate against employees who refuse to be vaccinated because of their religious beliefs, and also on the basis of creed — a system of non-religious beliefs that may be integral to a persons self-identity and standard for conduct, which arguably may include the anti-vaccination movement.

    Read more: COVID-19 vaccine passport development must have legal and ethics expert input: medical journal

    Recommended Reading: How Long Do You Have To Wait Between Vaccines

    Time Off For Vaccination

    Do we have to allow employees time off during working hours to receive a vaccination?

    There is no general right in law for an employee to have time off for medical appointments, but we expect most employers will allow time off for Covid vaccinations and there are many cogent reasons to do so:

    • Contracts and policies may include rights around attending medical appointments.
    • Employees who are clinically vulnerable may be classed as disabled under the EqA and allowing time off for vaccination could be regarded as a reasonable adjustment.
    • Employers have a legal obligation to provide a safe place of work and minimise risks for all employees. This could include enabling vaccination to take place.
    • An unreasonable refusal to allow time off for vaccination amid a global pandemic could be a breach of trust and confidence, which could prompt constructive dismissal claims.
    • Employment law issues aside, there could be negative PR implications from refusing to allow staff to attend vaccination appointments.

    There is no legal requirement for employees to be paid for time off, although there are calls for this right to be introduced. In practice, many employers will allow paid time off for medical appointments. Some employers may wish to offer paid time off as an incentive .

    Can we ask employees to change their appointment to a more convenient time?

    What if the employee feels unwell after getting the vaccine?

    Can Employers Ask Workers If They Got The Vaccine

    Can employers require the COVID-19 vaccine and can they legally ask if you’ve been vaccinated?

    Employers may require workers to disclose whether theyve received the vaccine, similarly to how they can ask for other medical evidence such as sick notes, according to Tiwari.

    Employers have a duty to provide a safe workplace and the vaccination status of workers can be important information to have in order to do this.

    However, employers need to be careful, he said.

    It matters how much information the employer requires, as too much personal health information could result in a breach of privacy. Employers are advised to limit questions to whether the employee has received a vaccine, and which brand they received. The latter may be important in the future if certain vaccines turn out to be effective only for a limited time, said Tiwari.

    This requirement should be clearly stated in a policy that explains what type of supporting documentation is required .

    You May Like: How Much Are Kitten Vaccinations At Petco

    Can Employers Share Workers Vaccination Information

    Co-workers and other visitors to the business might be concerned about their safety and ask whether all or specific workers on shift have been vaccinated.

    Employers do not have the right to disclose their workers personal health information as it is private, and they have a duty to protect the confidentiality of workers medical records. This sensitive information may only be shared with others where it pertains to the employers duty to accommodate their employee, said Tiwari.

    To assure co-workers and visitors of their safety, employers can confirm that the employee in question has been screened according to health and safety guidelines and is able to work.

    Response #: You Can’t Tell Anyone About Myvaccination Status

    That is partially true. The Americans with Disabilities Act generally requires that employers maintain theconfidentiality of any medical information they receive from orabout an employee, including vaccination status. There areexceptions to this rule, however. Human resources representativesmay disclose this information, for example, to supervisors ormanagers if the information is needed to provide job dutyrestrictions, to analyze and implement reasonable accommodations,or to enforce work rules . Keep in mind that any such disclosuresmust be on a “need to know” basis, and the amount ofinformation shared should be limited to only the amount necessaryto accomplish the stated purpose.

    Recommended Reading: Can You Get Meningitis If You Have Been Vaccinated

    Can Employers Ask Employees About Covid

    May 26, 2021HIPAA guideHIPAA Articles0

    In the United States, mask mandates are starting to be lifted and people who have been fully vaccinated against COVID-19 are now not required to wear a mask, so can employers ask employees about COVID-19 vaccinations and their current vaccine status before allowing them back to the workplace or to work without a facemask, or would that constitute a HIPAA violation?

    There has been considerable confusion about HIPAA and COVID-19 vaccinations and how the Rules of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act apply in such situations. Even in government, not everyone appears to be aware of when the HIPAA Rules apply and to whom.

    Recently, in defiance of House Rules, several GOP members refused to wear masks on the House floor even though they had not been fully vaccinated, and Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene claimed that asking about her COVID-19 vaccine status was a HIPAA violation, showing a lack of understanding about HIPAA and to whom the legislation applies.

    Employers are not prohibited from asking their employees if they have been vaccinated against COVID-19 and there are no federal laws that prohibit an employer or business from asking for proof of vaccination status. If an employer asks an employee about their vaccine status, the employee can refuse to answer, but there could well be consequences.

    Popular Articles
    Related news