Natural Immunity Alone Is Weak
One study compared natural immunity alone to natural immunity plus vaccination. They found that, after infection, unvaccinated people are 2.34 times likelier to get COVID-19 again, compared to fully vaccinated people. So vaccinated people have half the risk of reinfection than people relying on natural immunity alone.
“Studies show that the vaccine gives a very good booster response if you’ve had COVID-19 before,” says Dr. Rupp.
Furthermore, there is no country on the globe in which natural infection and natural immunity has brought the pandemic under control. In countries like Iran or Brazil very high levels of natural infection have not prevented recurrent waves of infection.
Vaccine Antibodies Vs Coronavirus Infection Antibodies
Illustration of the SARS-CoV-2 structure.
Your body will make different antibodies in response to coronavirus infection than in response to vaccination.
One of these antibodies is called a âspike antibody,â meaning that the antibody is directed at the spikes that surround the virusâs outer shell. The antibody attaches itself to the spikes on the virus in order to prevent the virus from attaching to your bodyâs healthy cells and causing infection. These are the types of antibodies that COVID-19 vaccines aim to teach your body to make in order to protect against infection.
Natural infection with coronavirus will produce different antibodies. These antibodies can bind to not just the spike, but also to other viral proteins such as the nucleocapsid. Current COVID-19 vaccines in development do not lead to antibodies against the nucleocapsid protein.
Astrazeneca Vaccine May Give Longer
- AstraZeneca’s CEO said restricting the vaccine in older people may be behind European surge, which has not been in the UK
- Just 67 million doses of the jab have been distributed across the continent
- That is compared to 440 million doses of the Pfizer-BioNTech jab, which is also approved in the U.S.
- Britain’s neighbours are now starting to record higher intensive care rates despite having similar case rates
- In the U.S., three vaccines have been approved by the FDA: Pfizer-BioNTech, Moderna and Johnson & Johnson’s Janssen
- The AstraZeneca vaccine has not yet been approved in America after suffering numerous setbacks
You May Like: How Many People Get Vaccinated In Us
What You Need To Know About Covid
The booster doses do not fully work immediately.
COVID-19 booster shots are now authorized for anyone over the age of 18. For anyone hoping to get a COVID-19 booster dose before the Thanksgiving holiday, experts say it’s important to understand that protection doesn’t kick in right away.
Although the body starts to increase antibodies within a few days after the shot, it takes two weeks for peak protection to return.
There is a meaningful increase in antibody titers by one week and peak responses at 2 weeks following mRNA boosting, said Dr. Dan Barouch, director of the Center for Virology and Vaccine Research at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston.
More than 32 million people in the U.S. have already received a COVID-19 booster dose. The FDA and CDC say it’s safe to mix and match boosters.
COVID-19 booster shots are composed of the same formulation as the current COVID-19 vaccines. But the Moderna vaccine booster is given at half the dose of the primary Moderna series.
Studies show the immunity gained from the primary vaccine series may decline over time — particularly protection against mild breakthrough infections. Therefore, experts recommend booster vaccination to increase immunity.
How Antibodies Prevent Infections
After an infection, certain T cells and B cells that can recognize the virus stick around for a long time. Then, when they are re-exposed to the virus , these special memory cells recognize it quickly and respond.
When this happens, you dont get sick. Or, if you do get sick, you usually only get a very mild version of an illness.
This is called protective immunity to a disease. Depending on the situation, this immunity might last for months or years.
You might also have partial immunity. This is like giving the immune system a head start that offers you some degree of protection, but not total protection.
Don’t Miss: What Vaccines Do You Get When Pregnant
How Long Do Covid Antibodies Last
Weâve previously found that vaccine-induced protection from COVID starts to fade after a number of months.
In this new research we found that people still had anti-N antibodies at least 9 months after infection, suggesting that protection through natural infection might be longer lasting than vaccine-induced immunity.
However, weâve also discovered that protection through natural immunity is less effective overall than vaccination, so we would always recommend you get vaccinated as soon as youâre eligible.
Our data shows that two doses of the AstraZeneca vaccine give 71% protection against infection, while two doses of the Pfizer vaccine provide 87% protection. But an unvaccinated person with a previous COVID infection has only 65% protection against catching it again.
However, being vaccinated on top of having had COVID provides even better protection – two doses of the AstraZeneca vaccine plus a previous COVID infection give 90% protection, while having COVID plus two Pfizer doses provide 95% protection.
How Long Will Immunity Last
It is very likely that for COVID-19 vaccine, given that the length of immunity the vaccine generates is limited, we may have to be vaccinated annually, Chunhuei Chi, ScD, MPH, director of the Center for Global Health at Oregon State Universitys College of Public Health and Human Sciences, tells Verywell.
In this regard, the COVID-19 vaccines currently available are not unusual. Most vaccines, Chi says, have their specific duration of immunity that can range from a few months to decades. The flu vaccine, which immunizes against seasonal influenza for several months, represents one end of the spectrum the measles vaccine, which immunizes against measles for life, represents the other. The magnitude of variation, Chi says, is the result of the unique combination of characteristics of viruses and vaccines.
The hope, Jere McBride, PhD, director of the experimental pathology graduate program at the University of Texas Medical Branch, tells Verywell, is that the Moderna and Pfizer-BioNTech vaccines will confer immunity for two to three years. In reality, however, the duration could be longer or shorter and will only be determined by conducting studies of people who have received the vaccine.
On April 1, 2021, Pfizer announced that an updated analysis of its Phase 3 trial showed that the vaccine was 91% percent effective overall and 100% effective in preventing severe disease for up to six months.
You May Like: How Do Vaccines Work To Protect The Body From Disease
How Does Natural Immunity Compare With Covid
According to data, immunity to SARS-CoV-2 after recovery has more breadth, is more robust, and is longer lasting than the immunity provided by the Covid-19 vaccines.
For the vaccinated, immunity wanesprogressively over just a few months, necessitating booster shots. And we have yet to learn how long this need for boosters will continue.
The immune systems of people who have received a Covid-19 vaccine and were never infected with SARS-CoV-2 have only seen the spike of the virus and, as a result, that is all that their immune systems remember. On the other hand, the immune systems of people with prior infection, have learned to recognize and respond to a multitude of different viral protein structures. Because most of the viral variants only differ by 5% from the original virus, people who have recovered from prior infection are better prepared to face variants.
Even before mid-June 2021, when the waning effect of the Covid-19 vaccines became apparent in Israel , prior infection provided comparable if not better protection than the vaccines. These findings were echoed from multiple studies from other countries.
In the literature there are significant differences between the immune response of the vaccinated compared to those with natural infection and those differences have been observed repeatedly.
First What About Immunity Following Covid
The presence of antibodies against SARS-CoV-2 is used as an indicator of immunity, with higher levels indicating greater protection. Once antibody levels drop below a particular threshold, or vanish completely, the person is at risk of reinfection.
Initially, scientists observed peoples antibody levels rapidly decreased shortly after recovery from COVID-19.
However, more recently, weve seen positive signs of long-lasting immunity, with antibody-producing cells in the bone marrow identified seven to eight months following infection with COVID-19. In addition, scientists have observed evidence of memory T cells more than six months following infection.
A study of over 9,000 recovered COVID-19 patients in the United States up to November 2020 showed a reinfection rate of only 0.7%. These findings closely align with a slightly more recent study suggesting reinfection after COVID-19 is very uncommon, at least in the short term.
Read more:5 ways our immune responses to COVID vaccines are unique
While it seems likely theres some level of lasting protection following COVID-19 infection, if youve had COVID, getting vaccinated is still worthwhile.
Theres some evidence vaccination after recovery leads to a stronger level of immunity compared to natural immunity from infection, or immunity from vaccination alone. People with so-called hybrid immunity appear to exhibit a more diverse range of antibodies.
Read Also: Where Can I Get A Meningitis Vaccine
A Look At How Antibodies From A Covid
COVID-19 vaccine clinic.
Since the COVID-19 vaccines have rolled out, theres been a lot of talk about the production of antibodies and how it correlates to the effectiveness of the shot as well as how it protects people who had actual coronavirus infections.
Though antibody responses are important to prevent viruses from invading the body, memory B and T cells play a significant role when fighting infection, according to researchers at the University of Pennsylvania. They followed people fully vaccinated with mRNA vaccines some of whom never had COVID-19 and others who had previously had the virus to measure their immune responses.
As expected, antibodies waned over time, but memory B and T cells persisted for at least six months, which might suggest steady and durable protection from severe disease and hospitalization as a result of the virus, according to the Penn Medicine study published in Science.
Waning immunity has been a hot topic in recent months as breakthrough COVID infections, though rare, have been reported, and as boosters have been recommended for certain groups of people whose immune responses become less robust over time.
The effectiveness of the COVID-19 vaccine often is correlated with the production of antibodies. But there are other parts of the immune system that can help fight the virus.
The immune system also generates memory T cells that detect and tackle viruses once inside the body.
What Has Seronet Learned About The Effects Of Covid
Dr. Klemm: Theres evidence coming out about some cancer patients not mounting a strong response to the COVID-19 vaccines. Several SeroNet groups are following vaccinated cancer patients to measure their immune response over time. The CDC is now recommending that moderately to severely immunocompromised people who received an mRNA vaccine get an additional dose of the same vaccine. That includes people who are actively getting treatment for blood cancer, those who have received a stem cell transplant within the last 2 years, and those who are taking medicine to suppress the immune system.
Dr. Finstad: I want to mention that the effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines is not the same for everyone with cancer. Weve seen that some people with blood cancers and some people undergoing immunosuppressive therapies don’t mount a robust antibody response. But if you’re a cancer survivorif youve finished treatment and are in remissionyou’re more likely to be able to mount a robust immune response to the vaccine.
The other thing is, the pandemic has really opened up a lot of questions, not just about COVID-19 vaccines but also about other vaccines: When would be the best time for people with cancer to be vaccinatedwhile they’re undergoing active therapy, or should they wait until some of their treatments are done? Does vaccine response depend on what type of treatment theyre getting?
Also Check: Is Flumist A Live Vaccine
Do We Need A Certain Level Of Covid
Dr. Finstad: We dont know that level yet. But given the evidence so far, public health experts are suggesting booster shots for the COVID-19 vaccines. This guidance is awaiting authorization from CDC and FDA.
More research is needed to determine what level of COVID-19 antibodies is protective, and this is an active area of investigation within SeroNet. For measles, for example, antibody testing is used as a surrogate measure to determine whether you’re protected from a future infectionits called a correlate of protection. If you are above that antibody level, you’re likely protected. And vice versaif you fall below that level, your physician will likely give you a booster to raise your antibody levels again.
By following individuals over time through SeroNet studies, we’ll be able to take a look at the antibody levels that correlate with protection. For COVID-19 vaccines, protection means you are protected from developing severe disease, but it doesnt mean you cant get infected. One SeroNet group actually wrote a very helpful article that explains how the vaccines can protect against illness but dont completely prevent you from getting infected.
What Happened In The Past
The 1918 influenza pandemic was far the deadliest respiratory virus pandemic recorded in recent human history with over 50 million deaths worldwide. Although they used some of the same measures we are using now , the deaths slowed only after enough of the population had either acquired immunity through natural infection or died. Indeed, the first influenza vaccine was not developed until 1942, more than 20 years later. As judged by the amount of suffering and death from 1918 influenza , natural immunity is obviously a terrible way to get through a pandemic.
Similarly, measles was a highly transmissible respiratory virus that led to high levels of immunity among adults who were invariably exposed as children. However, measles led to deaths each year among the nonimmune until a vaccine was developed in 1963, largely restricting current measles outbreaks in the U.S. now to populations who decline to vaccinate. Smallpox also led to high levels of immunity through natural infection, which was often fatal. That’s why unleashing smallpox on a largely nonimmune population in the New World was so deadly. Only an effective vaccine and its administration worldwide, including among populations who declined smallpox vaccine at first via mandates could control and then eventually eradicate smallpox from Earth.
Fully vaccinated people are already now able to generate some antibodies against all the variants we know of to date, thanks to their bank of memory B cells.
Read Also: How Many People Have Been Vaccinated In Illinois
Antibodies From Natural Infection
When you develop antibodies through illness, your immune system reacts to protect you. First, it goes through a process of identifying the virus and eventually making effective antibodies.
Your B cells make antibodies to different parts of the virus. Some of the antibodies your body makes are effective, and some are not. These help you eliminate the virus and recover.
Hopefully, some of these antibodies also help protect you from future infections. For example, infection with COVID-19 seems to give you some protection from being re-infected, at least in the short term. However, it is still unknown how long that protection lasts.
Vaccine data as of August 2021 shows that the odds of being reinfected with COVID-19 are 2.34 times greater for those who are unvaccinated than those who have received COVID-19 vaccination.
Also, studies have indicated that people with symptoms of COVID-19 seem to produce effective, neutralizing antibodies. From experience with other viruses, scientists think it means that getting infected with COVID-19 probably leads to at least some level of protection against future infection.
Additionally, animal studies suggest at least some level of protective immunity, with at least some of this coming from antibody protection.
In Addition To Antibodies Do Other Parts Of The Immune System Play A Role In The Response To Sars
Dr. Klemm: We do talk a lot about antibodies, but SeroNet actually studies the immune response to SARS-CoV-2 more broadly. Several lines of evidence suggest that T cells play an important role in the response to the coronavirus. For example, one SeroNet study found T cells that recognize SARS-CoV-2 in blood samples obtained from people who had recovered from COVID-19.
Microscope image of a T cell, a type of immune cell that protects the body from infection.
And it appears that T cells contribute to protection from infection, at least in lab animals. In one study, nonhuman primates that lacked T cells were more susceptible to reinfection with SARS-CoV-2.
But we’re just scratching the surface of understanding the T-cell response to SARS-CoV-2 here. Theres still a lot of important research to be done to answer questions about the role of T cells in fighting COVID-19.
Dr. Finstad: One of the things that makes T-cell studies more difficult to do in large populations is that tests of T cell functionality take a lot of time, are expensive, and require a larger blood sample than antibody tests.
Also Check: Is The Shingles Vaccine Covered Under Medicare